People do not care how much you know until they know how much you care.
— Teddy Roosevelt

Our goal is to listen more than talk, show empathy, and try to look at each situation from the customer’s perspective. The goal is not to wear you down or impress you with your with our smarts. The goal is to solve the problems and make things right as we move toward the closing for your home.

Screen Shot 2020-01-07 at 6.12.34 PM.png

“Amy is by far the most nicest and sharpest person to do the business with. Thank you for keeping us on top of things and help us sell our home in 2 days of listing and purchase our dream home at the same time. We are very happy at our new home. We really appreciate everything you did for us! We highly recommend Amy!”

— Maya Tayake Pazzelli, Dublin

Screen Shot 2020-03-07 at 6.05.50 PM.png
The McGee Farm

The McGee Farm

1890s Charm

1890s Charm

“I have known Amy Bumpus for 10 years. Our sons (her 2 and my 3) are close in age, and they were in classes and activities together in school. We grew from acquaintances to the closest of friends. My family has shared many wonderful moments with her family. We have gone through difficult life events together as well. I trust Amy as a mother and as a precious friend. I know her heart for her family. I know her heart for her friends and for her community. And, I know her heart for her work as a realtor. I have seen the efforts firsthand that Amy has gone to for her clients over the years I have known her. She feels a tremendous responsibility for her clients. She gets to know them and shares, and takes to heart, her clients' disappointments and joys. I have seen the late (and the early AM) hours, the bargaining, the many miles traveling around, the dealing with intricate and unique situations, the expectations versus reality, the impossible becoming possible. She is intelligent, diligent, knowledgeable, forthright, aggressive when called for, current, and she truly CARES. So, when my husband and I made the decision to sell the home we had raised our sons in and search for a new place to call home, we were absolutely confident Amy was the realtor to trust. Not because she was our friend, but because of the experience of years of seeing her work so hard and care so much for so many people. We knew she would give us an honest and realistic expectation of the condition and sale value of our home, and do the same with any house we looked at purchasing. Amy can evaluate quickly what needs to be updated or changed in order for your house to sell. She can help you prioritize in order to stay within your budget, and is unerringly honest and realistic and practical. She also has a network of professionals she can recommend to do needed work or upgrades that you are not able to accomplish yourself, and that will do the work in a timely fashion and within the estimate you are given before work begins. This is also true for when you are buying a home. Amy works to find the best possible fit for your budget and for the priorities you have in your home search. She knows the market well. She researches and stays current with sale trends and quality and resale values. She can point out issues and also ease concerns about a home. She has that network to call upon, too. We had built our Westerville home in a nice subdivision, close to the schools, and a wonderful community of neighbors, and lived there for 17 1/2 years. We wanted to find a new place to call home with a few country acres, and to pass along our Westerville home to a new family to love. We listened to Amy's advice, and made updates over a 1 1/2 month period. Amy had the house in contract the day it went on the market. She helped us find and purchase our home in Delaware during the time our Westerville place was updated and in contract. So much went into making both transactions possible, and Amy was with us and working for us every step of the way. To say "Above and Beyond" seems trite and overused, but that is, nonetheless, entirely accurate when describing what Amy Bumpus does as a realtor. I know this has been a long review, but I owe the same care in reviewing and recommending Amy that she has given in working for us. Amy cares, but not just about selling/buying a property. She understands you are selling what has been your HOME, and knows how to help that transition. She cares about finding you a place, too. Not just a place to live, Amy wants to find you a place to call HOME, for however long you stay. If you want to sell your current home, if you want to buy a home, or if you want both...my friend, Amy Bumpus, is the realtor you want working for you.”

— Patricia McGee, Delaware

Screen Shot 2020-01-07 at 6.22.00 PM.png

“I would recommend Amy Bumpus to anyone wanting to buy or sell a house. Her knowledge and experience made my purchase of a new home flawless. She was right there with me through the entire process. She is always one step ahead and gets things done incredible fast. Amy is amazing!”

— Denise Lees-Yohe, Olde Worthington

Screen Shot 2020-01-07 at 6.18.25 PM.png

“Amy and Jan's realtor expertise just blew me away - both on the buying and the selling sides of the table. They listed my house early in June, and we closed the sale on July 31. I can't imagine dealing with any team more caring and more professional.”

—Dianne Katzenmoyer, Westerville

Screen Shot 2020-01-07 at 6.28.32 PM.png

“Amy sold my Ohio condo as I was called to California to work. There were so many details she and her team facilitated. She stayed in contact by email, phone and text in a way that I was never concerned about progress. She worked with contractors, title agency and even my neighbors to make the sale. Most importantly, I grew to trust Amy completely. Her personality and confidence provided great comfort during a very hectic time. Highly recommend.”

— Michael Barber, Worthington

Screen Shot 2020-01-07 at 6.31.43 PM.png

“Excellent realty services! Amy supports your needs as a buyer or seller, and is there for you through every step of the process.”

— Gerrie Brand, Westerville

Screen Shot 2020-01-07 at 6.36.54 PM.png

“Our daughter introduced my husband and me to Amy Bumpus several years ago. We had several 'failed' attempts in securing jobs but Amy never flinched or reacted in a way that made us feel we weren't meeting 'her needs'. It was always about us and what we needed. I especially appreciated that when we told her our price range she showed us homes within our comfort zone and never tried to bump it up. When our current situation brought us back once again to Columbus, Amy was diligent to work 'in our behalf'. She went the extra mile to explore ways to 'save us money', not spend ours. I gladly will continue to recommend her to friends and neighbors. I am so grateful I have personally assisted 2 clients to choose Amy as their realtor! They couldn't say enough 'great things' about her!”

— Lynn Geiger, Dublin

Screen Shot 2020-01-07 at 11.12.17 PM.png

“Working with Amy through Benedum & Bumpus Coldwell Banker was an excellent experience for my husband I. We had a very unique situation that required Amy to handle a tremendous amount of correspondence with the seller's real estate agent and real estate attorneys. It was a long process (at no fault to Amy) but she prevailed. Amy really knows her stuff and because she does, she was able to provide "out-of-the-box" ideas in order to get us our dream home. She never stopped trying and I'm forever thankful. Today we are renovating our dream home purchase, and I can already see it's character and beauty that will soon become our forever home.
Thank you Amy!”

— Jamie Schwanekamp, Westerville

Screen Shot 2020-01-08 at 11.17.08 AM.png

Customer Ratings & Testimonials

Just click to see more testimonials from our valued clients. We strive to always go above and beyond and truly be like a business partner in the process of selling & buying homes for our clients; protecting your interests by sharing our knowledge and helping you make the best decisions possible.